Dissecting the New Market Volatility, and How to Profit
James Cullen
I’d like to address the market volatility from two perspectives - one heavily statistical and trading-oriented, and the other from a more qualitative and long-term approach tomorrow.
Market volatility, as measured by the CBOE Volatility Index (VIX), is at a 52-week high. Many of the CNBC-type soundbites from this bull market - terms like “awash in liquidity,†“double-digit earnings growth,†and “low volatility environment†- have become taken for granted. Much of that complacency (which is evident by a low VIX reading) has been shaken out in the past few weeks, and the VIX quickly rallied to new highs. To put this into perspective, the current VIX reading of 28.3 at Friday’s close (or higher) has only occurred on 9.3% of all trading days. While that might not sound too extreme - what is once every eleven days? - the lumpy distribution of occurrences is quite striking, as seen on the chart below. Every black line represents a day where the VIX closed at or higher than it did on Friday.

Because volatility tends to rise as the markets fall, being “long†volatility is a way to hedge your portfolio. I’ve seen volatility hedging discussed, but I’m not interested in hedging with volatility right now.
Actually, I’d prefer to speculate on the short side of volatility - which you could do by setting up a synthetic short position by selling a call and buying a put at (or near) the same strike price. While this can be dangerous if you build your position into a tower of leverage, having a straight synthetic short on a fairly distant month’s calls (I’d prefer November or December right now) looks to be a high probability setup as a downward break in the VIX should occur between now and then, allowing you to profit handily thanks to the leverage of the synthetic position. I’ve modeled out a few possibilities, and the November 18s look to have adequate liquidity to work in a short call and a long put. Break-even there would come as the VIX goes under 23, and looking for a 35% drop in the VIX to 18 gives a target profit for the trade of $470 per synthetic position (one call and one put) on a $470 credit (the trade is cash flow positive).
I’ll admit that this is an unusual trade suggestion because:
1. I don’t normally do trade suggestions
2. Shorting volatility has gotten many bright people in trouble (see: Long-Term Capital Mangement)
Still, as I increase the volatility close parameter up, there is a rapid decrease in probability VIX continues higher. See the chart below for an idea of how increases in the VIX fall off.

What does this all amount to? Odds are heavily in favor of the VIX falling in the very near future, and hence it might be prudent speculation (not an oxymoron) to examine ways to profit from such a move. Buying puts is quite obvious, but given that the VIX is not a tradable index, I thought it would also be good to highlight the usefulness of synthetic stock positions here.
See more Uncategorized |

August 19th, 2007 at 1:09 pm
[...] I wrote about how, with volatility near a historic high, you should consider speculating by being short volatility. The market conditions of late have been strange; if you are a quant and go strictly by statistics, [...]
August 19th, 2007 at 9:41 pm
[...] list, but with the widespread selling knowing who is buying can be revealing knowledge. With the historically high volatility in the markets, many stocks across several different sectors have been whipsawed around, so another [...]
August 26th, 2007 at 12:53 am
[...] previous Friday. This coincided with the CBOE Volatility Index (VIX) dropping 30% and making this synthetic short trade look very good. While I think we are far from out of the woods on this credit mess, I’m not [...]